Introduction
The global volume of pesticide usage has increased significantly over the last decade. In addition to the increase in the number of pesticides used to combat pest resistance to pesticides, farmers use other methods, such as stronger concentrations of pesticides, increased frequency of pesticide usage, and increased combination of several pesticides
1, 2. The World Health Organization (WHO) reported that in 2016, there were more than 150,000 deaths and 7,.000,000 poisoning cases caused by pesticide usage worldwide
3. Ninety-nine percent of acute poisonings have occurred in developing countries, indicating the need to prevent exposure to pesticides. Farmers, agricultural sector workers, and their families are at higher risk of direct and indirect exposure to pesticides
4-6. Greenhouse workers are also exposed to elevated levels of pesticides compared to other occupations, due to the use of pesticides in a relatively closed space, higher dosage of pesticide, and co-occurrence of exposure to pesticide with exposure to high temperature and humidity, which could increase the absorbance of these chemicals into the human body
7. One of the most important health effects caused by exposure to pesticides is the permanent and irreversible damage to the nervous system
8-10. The results of epidemiological studies have shown that there is a relationship between exposure to pesticides and the incidence of cognitive impairment
11, 12. Neurological disorders are the most frequent (41%) health effects of pesticides exposure
13. Organophosphates pesticides are one of the most widely used pesticides worldwide, are well-known for their effects on the central nervous system by inhibiting acetylcholinesterase (AChE), the enzyme that transfers acetylcholine levels
14-18. Moreover, exposure to some organophosphates pesticides appears to be associated with chronic neurological complications
19. There is some evidence that prolonged exposure to pesticides can cause serious neurological consequences, such as cognitive impairments, including verbal memory, nonverbal memory, prospective memory, psychomotor speed, selective attention, divided attention, and spatial functioning
20-22. The results of the study by Dawson-Jaime Butler et al
., showed that exposure to pesticides may be associated with learning disabilities, especially in motor functions
23. In the study by Ebrahimzadeh et al., a significant difference was observed between the activity of cholinesterase enzyme in rice field workers and the control group
24. The present study aimed to determine and compare the exposure to pesticides with cholinesterase activity and cognitive impairment, using semi-quantitative exposure assessment method. The subjects were divided into three groups, including those with direct exposure to pesticides (greenhouse workers), those with indirect exposure (residents in the proximity of the greenhouses), and those with no exposure (control group). Then, the association between pesticide exposure, AChE activity, and cognitive assessment results, including Frontal Assessment Battery (FAB) and Mini-mental State Examination (MMSE) was assessed.
Materials and Methods
Participants and study area
This cross-sectional study was carried out in 2019 in Ahmadabad village of Yazd province, Iran. The study population consisted of three groups with different pesticide exposure scenarios, including direct exposure group, indirect exposure group, and control group. The subjects in all the three groups were relatively similar in terms of age, gender, and health status. The sample size was calculated based on the statistical level of 0.05, and power of 80%, based on the effect size reported in the study by Sebastian et al.
16 They used the Rey–Osterrieth Complex Figure (ROCF) test for the assessment of cognitive function in a group of greenhouse workers
16.
Finally, 60 workers from the direct exposure group, 31 people of the indirect exposure group, and 30 people from the control group participated in the study. The inclusion criteria included having at least one year of work experience in a greenhouse for the direct exposure group, living at least one year in the proximity of greenhouses (at a distance of 3 to 8 km from the greenhouse) for the indirect exposure group, and having none of the above conditions in addition to not being employed in the agricultural sector for the control group
25. Moreover, those with congenital, metabolic or chronic diseases, and family history of neurologic diseases were not included. We also excluded those who took any medication affecting the nervous system function. The participants were in the age range of 20-70 years.
Exposure assessment
Direct exposure assessment was not done in this study due to the difficulty of accessing analytical methods for measuring pesticides. Therefore, the modified version of a semi-quantitative pesticide exposure model was used based on the study conducted by Negatu et al. in Ethiopia
26. A semi-quantitative pesticide exposure algorithm has been extensively used and evaluated by different field monitoring studies and has had a good correlation with post-application urinary concentration of pesticide biomarkers. This is an inexpensive and easily adaptable method for pesticide applicators and farm workers exposure assessment. Cumulative applicator exposure was defined by multiplying variables of greenhouse workers’ work experience, the area under cultivation per year, and spraying frequency in a recent month (Equation 1).
Cumulative applicator exposure = work experience× area under cultivation× spraying frequency (Equation 1)
Outcomes assessment
AChE activity: AChE activity related to pesticide exposure in the three groups were assessed base on the German Society for Clinical Chemistry (DGKC) standard method
27. Venous blood (5 ml) was taken from all the participants. Blood samples were centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 10 minutes and
serum was separated. The cholinesterase assay was performed on a diluted sample using butyrylthiocholine substrate present in the reagent to form butyrate and thiocholine. Thiocholine, in presence of potassium hexacyanoferrate (III), reduces the yellow-colored hexacyanoferrate III to colorless potassium hexacyanoferrate (II). The decrease in absorbance is directly related to the activity of serum cholinesterase in the sample (All the procedures was done in a certified medical laboratory).
Cognitive outcomes
The FAB and MMSE were used to assess the cognitive function of all three study groups. The FAB test included 6 questions related to similarities (conceptualization), lexical fluency (mental flexibility), motor series "Luria" test (programming), conflicting instructions (sensitivity to interference), go/no-go (inhibitory control), and comprehension behavior (environmental autonomy). Each FAB test score was between a minimum of 0 and a maximum of 3 and the total score was of maximum of 18
28. The MMSE test is a 20-point questionnaire used to evaluate different cognitive domains, such as memory, visual function, executive function, and
etc. Each question of the MMSE test was scored as either correct or incorrect; the total score ranged from 0 to 30, the higher score represents better cognitive performance
29.
Covariates
The data were collected by a researcher-made checklist comprised of six sections, including demographic information of the participants, the way of preparing pesticides, the way of working with pesticides, using personal protective equipment’s during spraying, individual health, and specifications of the greenhouse where the participants work. Moreover, information of indirect exposure and control groups was obtained by another questionnaire, including demographic characteristics, disease history, and tobacco and alcohol use.
Data analysis
The data were analyzed by R software version 3.5, using one-way multivariate test (ANOVA), t-test, and Tukey post hoc test. Multiple linear regression models were used to determine the relationship between exposure, and AChE, MMSE, and FAB as outcome. The significance level was considered 0.05 in all tests. Three different regression models were defined according to the level of adjustment. The first model was the crude model. The second model (model 1) was adjusted for age and education. The third model (model 2) was additionally adjusted for smoking status and body mass index (BMI).
Ethical Issue
Informed consent was taken from all the participants before participating in the study. The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, and the protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences (IR.SSU.SPH.REC.1397.053 - 2018-08-04).
Results
The demographic information of the participants is presented in table 1. All the subjects were male and their age was in the range of 32-35 years (mean = 33.24). Most of the participants (89 %) had high school and lower education. The highest BMI was for the indirect exposure group, and the highest prevalence of smoking (18%) was for the direct exposure group.
We found better cognitive performance in those with higher education (Figure 1).
Discussion
In this study, we found that the mean AChE activity in the direct exposure group was lower than the other two groups and the mean was approximately equal in the indirect exposure and control groups. The lower activity of cholinesterase enzyme in greenhouse workers can be an indication of their exposure to pesticides, leading to the production of free radicals and oxidative stress and confirms the absorption of pesticides in their bodies
30. Other similar studies have been conducted in high-risk regions. The results of these studies have shown that the acetylcholinesterase activity of farmers is probably lower than that of the general population
31, 32.
The results of cognitive assessment in this study showed that the cognitive function score for MMSE was significantly different in the direct exposure and control groups and the mean FAB score in the control group was 1.55 point higher than the direct exposure group. The mean MMSE score in the control group was 2.55 point higher than the direct exposure group. The results of investigating the relationship between pesticide exposure and neurological cognitive function in greenhouse workers showed a decrease in processing speed, poorer function in visual and motor coordination, and visual and working memory skills compared to the control group. Therefore, exposure to pesticides potentially has adverse health effects on individuals' mental and behavioral functions. Similar studies have been conducted on farmers' cognitive function, which are consistent with the results of the present study. Ismail et al
., reported that the results of all functional tests, such as attention, visual, verbal, and perceptual showed a significant decrease in neurobehavioral function in the exposure group compared to the control group
33.
The results of a study on Chinese farmers showed that poisoning with pesticides is associated with reduced response rates, short-term memory deficits, as well as loss of coordination. Poorer function in hearing, speed, accuracy, and visual perception tests was observed in the direct exposure group compared to the control group
34. MMSE cognitive test results in the study of Baldi et al
. showed that chronic exposure to pesticides reduces cognitive function, and long-term exposure causes the risk of dementia
35, which is in line with the results of the present study.
Limited studies have been conducted on the health effects of pesticides on the residents in the proximity of agricultural areas. The results of the cognitive assessment showed that the cognitive function score for both the FAB and MMSE tests in the indirect exposure group was higher than the direct exposure group; however, this difference was not significant. Furthermore, the FAB cognitive test score was not significantly different in the indirect exposure and control groups; however, the MMSE test showed a significant difference between the two groups. This difference might be due to the fact that the MMSE test covers a broader set of cognitive domains
36. Sebastian et al. reported that the direct exposure group performed significantly poorer in the executive function, verbal fluency, and visual and auditory memory tests compared to the indirect exposure group. The indirect exposure group was also at a lower level than the control group. Therefore, both direct and indirect exposure groups are affected by exposure to pesticides
16.
One of the important factors indicating the vulnerability of greenhouse workers is the number of years of formal education. Both FAB and MMSE cognitive tests were significantly correlated with education level. The results showed that the level of cholinesterase activity in the indirect exposure and control groups was significantly higher in the subjects with higher education level. Even in the indirect exposure group, the relationship was almost linear; since people with a higher education level were more aware or afraid of the health effects of pesticide exposure; therefore, they were less exposed to pesticides. The results of Sharifi et al
.'s study showed that one of the factors affecting the use of pesticides is the level of education and awareness
37. In the direct exposure group, there was no relationship between education level and the cholinesterase enzyme activity. However, using pesticides affects the health of low-educated people due to their inability to understand the guidelines, lack of awareness of how to read, or lack of information about the health effects of pesticides on the human body and the environment
38. However, the results of this study showed that academic education is not a good proxy for people’s health literacy level. In an interview with greenhouse workers, it was found that they did not use appropriate personal protective equipment, such as masks, long-sleeved gloves, long boots, hats, face covers, and regular shower after spraying and their only safety tool was some kind of cloth mask. Therefore, their exposure to pesticides increases and their cholinesterase activity decreases. In a similar study, Vikkey et al
. reported that education level did not affect the level of cholinesterase activity in cotton field workers
39. The FAB and MMSE cognitive test scores were significantly correlated with the education level, and those with higher education levels scored higher on each test. People with higher education usually have better understanding and expression in cognitive testing. This may lead to better function in cognitive tests and consequently later detection of pesticide effects on cognition
40. In the study of Cheng et al
., higher education level was associated with better scores on MTA (medial temporal lobe atrophy) cognitive test
41. In Carolyn et al.'s study, the MMSE cognitive test score was lower for people with lower education level
42. The results of these studies were consistent with the current study. In the direct exposure group, people with lower cholinesterase activity levels also had poorer cognitive function. However, the obtained results were not significant, which might be due to the limitations of the study and the lack of generalization of small sample size to the whole population. However, most of the previous studies have reported that occupational exposure to pesticides is associated with cognitive impairment
43-47. The results of the study by Kim et al. showed that exposure to chlorine organic pesticides was associated with the cognitive function measured by the Digit Symbol Substitution Test (DSST) in the US elders; however, it was not significant
48. The results of DSST and FAB tests were consistent with our study. Factors that have neurotoxic effects can cause a variety of problems, including mental retardation and disability, as well as changes in cognitive function, which largely depend on exposure to the chemical
49. According to the results, there was no significant relationship between FAB cognitive function score and MMSE of direct exposed subjects and exposure rate. Many other studies have shown a negative relationship between exposure to pesticides and various neurobehavioral functions
43, 50, 51, which is not in line with the findings of the present study, due to the intrinsic characteristic of the individuals
33. In the study by Ismail et al., no significant relationship was found between individuals' exposure and neurological function tests
52, which is consistent with the results of the current study.
Study limitations
This study had several limitations. First the sample size in the study was small and part of the null findings could be due to the power of the study. Second, although it was tried to use a previously used semi-quantitative exposure assessment method in the study, the validity of the approach was not tested in the target population and the obtained results by this method could be subject to exposure misclassification. Previous studies have shown that exposure to different pesticides is associated with cognitive impairment in different domains. However, in this study a general MMSE test was used which provides a clue about general cognitive impairment rather than domain-specific outcomes. However, the results of the more specific test (such as FAB) should also be interpreted with caution due to the limitation in the sample size.
Conclusion
This study aimed to determine the association between pesticide exposure and AChE activity and cognitive function in greenhouse workers and those living in the proximity of the greenhouses. The findings on the reduced level of cholinesterase activity in the greenhouse workers have been highlighted in previous studies. The findings on poorer cognitive function in the greenhouse workers and more importantly the residents in the proximity of the greenhouses are of great importance, which should be explored in future studies with larger sample size and using better exposure and outcome assessment methods. These findings highlight the importance of safety and health improvement programs for pesticides applications in agricultural sectors, especially greenhouse activities.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences.
Funding
The study was funded by Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences (Grant no: 5269 as a thesis of Mr. Akhoundzardeini).
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
This is an Open-Access article distributed in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon this work for commercial use.
References
1. Osteen CD, Fernandez Cornejo J. Economic and policy issues of US agricultural pesticide use trends. Manag Sci. 2013;69(9):1001-25.
2. Wilson C, Tisdell C. Why farmers continue to use pesticides despite environmental, health and sustainability costs. Ecological economics. 2001;39(3):449-62.
3. Siegel R, DeSantis C, Virgo K, et al. Cancer treatment and survivorship statistics, 2012. CA: Cancer J Clin. 2012;62(4):220-41.
4. Petroianu GA, Nurulain SM, Shafiullah M,
et al. Usefulness of administration of nonorganophosphate cholinesterase inhibitors before acute exposure to organophosphates: assessment using paraoxon. Journal of Applied Toxicology. 2013;33(9):894-900.
5. Vidi P-A, Anderson KA, Chen H, et al. Personal samplers of bioavailable pesticides integrated with a hair follicle assay of DNA damage to assess environmental exposures and their associated
risks in children. Mutation Research/Genetic Toxicology and Environmental Mutagenesis. 2017;822:27-33.
6. Miah SJ, Hoque A, Paul A, et al. Unsafe use of pesticide and its impact on health of farmers: a case study in Burichong Upazila, Bangladesh. cancer. 2014;21(3):22-30.
7. Kundiev YI, Krasnyuk E, Viter VP. Specific features of the changes in the health status of female workers exposed to pesticides in greenhouses. Toxicol Lett. 1986;33(1-3):85-9.
8. Ruiz-Guzmán JA, Gómez-Corrales P, Cruz-Esquivel Á, et al. Cytogenetic damage in peripheral blood lymphocytes of children exposed to pesticides in agricultural areas of the department of Cordoba, Colombia. Mutation Research/Genetic Toxicology and Environmental Mutagenesis. 2017;824:25-31.
9. Damalas CA, Koutroubas SD. Farmers’ exposure to pesticides: toxicity types and ways of prevention. Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute; 2016.
10. Dereumeaux C, Fillol C, Quénel P, et al. Pesticide exposures for residents living close to agricultural lands: A review. Environ Int. 2020;134:105210.
11. Dean JR, Fitzpatrick LJ. Pesticides defined by matrix. Elsevier; 2001.
12. Kim K-H, Kabir E, Jahan SA. Exposure to pesticides and the associated human health effects. Sci Total Environ. 2017;575:525-35.
13. Dhananjayan V, Ravichandran B. Occupational health risk of farmers exposed to pesticides in agricultural activities. Curr Opin Environ Sci Health. 2018;4:31-7.
14. Ross SJM, Brewin CR, Curran HV, et al. Neuropsychological and psychiatric functioning in sheep farmers exposed to low levels of organophosphate pesticides. Neurotoxicol Teratol. 2010;32(4):452-9.
15. Lee I, Eriksson P, Fredriksson A, et al. Developmental neurotoxic effects of two pesticides: Behavior and biomolecular studies on chlorpyrifos and carbaryl. Toxicology and applied pharmacology. 2015;288(3):429-38.
16. Corral SA, de Angel V, Salas N, et al. Cognitive impairment in agricultural workers and nearby residents exposed to pesticides in the Coquimbo Region of Chile. Neurotoxicology and teratology. 2017;62:13-9.
17. Garcia FP, Ascencio SYC, Oyarzún JCG, et al. Pesticides: classification, uses and toxicity. Measures of exposure and genotoxic risks. Res J Environ Toxicol. 2012;1(11):279-93.
18. Stein LJ, Gunier RB, Harley K, et al. Early childhood adversity potentiates the adverse association between prenatal organophosphate pesticide exposure and child IQ: The Chamacos cohort. Neurotoxicology. 2016;56:180-7.
19. Reed NR, Lim LO. Organophosphate Insecticides: Neurodevelopmental Effects. In: Nriagu JO, editor. Encyclopedia of Environmental Health. Burlington: Elsevier; 2011. p. 283-90.
20. Pimentel D, Burgess M. Environmental and economic costs of the application of pesticides primarily in the United States. J Integr Pest Manag: Springer; 2014. p. 47-71.
21. Carr RL, Graves CA, Mangum LC, et al. Low level chlorpyrifos exposure increases anandamide accumulation in juvenile rat brain in the absence of brain cholinesterase inhibition. Neurotoxicology. 2014;43:82-9.
22. Ramírez-Santana M, Zúñiga L, Corral S, et al. Assessing biomarkers and neuropsychological outcomes in rural populations exposed to organophosphate pesticides in Chile–study design and protocol. BMC Public Health. 2015;15(1):1-9.
23. Butler-Dawson J, Galvin K, Thorne PS, et al. Organophosphorus pesticide exposure and neurobehavioral performance in Latino children living in an orchard community. Neurotoxicology. 2016;53:165-72.
24. Shokrzadeh M, Bioukabadi M. Effect of organophosphorous pesticides on acetyl cholinesterase activity in agricultural workers. Journal of Shahrekord Uuniversity of Medical Sciences. 2005;7:14-20
25. Gunier RB, Bradman A, Castorina R, et al. Residential proximity to agricultural fumigant use and IQ, attention and hyperactivity in 7-year old children. Environmental research. 2017;158:358-65.
26. Negatu B, Vermeulen R, Mekonnen Y, et al. A method for semi-quantitative assessment of exposure to pesticides of applicators and re-entry workers: an application in three farming systems in Ethiopia. Ann Occup Hyg. 2016;60(6):669-83.
27. Wulandari DD, Santoso APR, Wulansari DD. The Effect of Beetroot (Beta vulgaris L.) Juice on Cholinesterase Activity in Farmers Exposed to Organophosphate Pesticides. IJMLST. 2019;1(2): 80-7.
28. Dubois B, Slachevsky A, Litvan I, et al. The FAB: a frontal assessment battery at bedside. Neurology. 2000;55(11):1621-6.
29. Cockrell JR, Folstein MF. Mini-mental state examination. Principles and practice of geriatric psychiatry. 2002:140-1.
30. Ayrami M, Hashemi T, Malekirad AA. Electroencephalogram, cognitive state, psychological disorders, clinical symptom, and oxidative stress in horticulture farmers exposed to organophosphate pesticides. Toxicol Ind Health. 2012;28(1):90-6.
31. Pathak M, Fareed M, Bihari V, et al. Cholinesterase levels and morbidity in pesticide sprayers in North India. Occupational Medicine. 2011;61(7):512-4.
32. Kachaiyaphum P, Howteerakul N, Sujirarat D, et al. Serum cholinesterase levels of Thai chilli-farm workers exposed to chemical pesticides: prevalence estimates and associated factors. Journal of occupational health. 2009;52(1):89-98.
33. Ismail AA, Bodner T, Rohlman D. Neurobehavioral performance among agricultural workers and pesticide applicators: a meta-analytic study. Occup Environ Med. 2012;69(7):457-64.
34. Muñoz-Quezada MT, Lucero BA, Iglesias VP, et al. Chronic exposure to organophosphate (OP) pesticides and neuropsychological functioning in farm workers: a review. Int J Occup Environ Health Int J Occup Env Heal. 2016;22(1):68-79.
35. Baldi I, Gruber A, Rondeau V, et al. Neurobehavioral effects of long-term exposure to pesticides: results from the 4-year follow-up of the phytoner study. Occupational and environmental medicine. 2011;68(2):108-15.
36. Jayasinghe SS. Effects of acute organophosphate ingestion on cognitive function, assessed with the mini mental state examination. J Postgrad Med. 2012;58(3):171.
37. Sharafi K, Pirsaheb M, Maleki S, et al. Knowledge, attitude and practices of farmers about pesticide use, risks, and wastes; a cross-sectional study (Kermanshah, Iran). Sci Total Environ. 2018;645:509-17.
38. Muñoz-Quezada MT, Lucero B, Iglesias V, et al. Exposure to organophosphate (OP) pesticides and health conditions in agricultural and non-agricultural workers from Maule, Chile. Int J Environ Health Res. 2017;27(1):82-93.
39. Vikkey HA, Fidel D, Elisabeth YP, et al. Risk factors of pesticide poisoning and cholinesterase inhibition with cotton workers from north of benin’republic (banikoara and kandi townships). BMJ Publishing Group Ltd; 2018.
40. Wattmo C, Londos E, Minthon L. Response to cholinesterase inhibitors affects lifespan in Alzheimer's disease. BMC neurology. 2014;14(1): 173.
41. Cheng YW, Chen TF, Cheng TW, et al. Hippocampal atrophy but not white-matter changes predicts the long-term cognitive response to cholinesterase inhibitors in Alzheimer’s disease. Alzheimer's Res Ther. 2015;7(1):1-8.
42. Zhu CW, Livote EE, Scarmeas N, et al. Long-term associations between cholinesterase inhibitors and memantine use and health outcomes among patients with Alzheimer's disease. Alzheimer's & Dementia. 2013;9(6):733-40.
43. Rohlman DS, Lasarev M, Anger WK, et al. Neurobehavioral performance of adult and adolescent agricultural workers. Neurotoxicology. 2007;28(2):374-80.
44. Stephens R, Sreenivasan B. Neuropsychological effects of long-term low-level organophosphate exposure in orchard sprayers in England. Arch Environ Health. 2004;59(11):566-74.
45. Wesseling C, Keifer M, Ahlbom A, et al. Long-term neurobehavioral effects of mild poisonings with organophosphate and n-methyl carbamate pesticides among banana workers. Int J Occup Environ Health Int J Occup Env Heal. 2002;8(1):27-34.
46. Wilaiwan W, Siriwong W. Assessment of health effects related to organophosphate pesticides exposure using blood cholinesterase activity as a biomarker in agricultural area at Nakhon Nayok province, Thailand. Journal of Health Research. 2014;28(1):23-30.
47. Suarez-Lopez JR, Hood N, Suárez-Torres J, et al. Associations of acetylcholinesterase activity with depression and anxiety symptoms among adolescents growing up near pesticide spray sites. Int J Hyg Envir Heal. 2019;222(7): 981-90.
48. Kim KS, Lee YM, Lee HW, et al. Associations between organochlorine pesticides and cognition in US elders: National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 1999–2002. Environ Int. 2015;75:87-92.
49. Jamal F, Haque QS, Singh S. Interrelation of glycemic status and neuropsychiatric disturbances in farmers with organophosphorus pesticide toxicity. Open Biochem J. 2016;10:27.
50. Eckerman DA, Gimenes LS, De Souza RC, et al. Age related effects of pesticide exposure on neurobehavioral performance of adolescent farm workers in Brazil. Neurotoxicology and teratology. 2007;29(1):164-75.
51. Rasoul GMA, Abou Salem ME, Mechael AA, et al. Effects of occupational pesticide exposure on children applying pesticides. Neurotoxicology. 2008;29(5):833-8.
52. Ismail AA, Bonner MR, Hendy O, et al. Comparison of neurological health outcomes between two adolescent cohorts exposed to pesticides in Egypt. PloS one. 2017;12(2): e0172696.